Hi everyone, Frank N. Foode speaking. I am delighted to see that discussions are really sprouting forth here at Biofortified. For the first time ever, one of our posts has gathered more than 100 comments, as both those in favor and against genetic engineering are engaging in healthy repartee. I am glad to see Duncan and Jasmine offering their perspectives on labeling issues. Reading the comments, it is almost as if everyone is surprised to be enjoying talking to each other!
In the tweetverse, I think I have made a new friend in Gavin (@morethanorganic), and although we both strongly disagree on both genetically engineered golden rice and cross-pollination issues, we both learned that we agree that sovereign nations should have the right to decide for themselves whether to allow their people to grow it. If I had thought that he was just another hard-line anti-GE person I might have thought that he believed that wealthy nations could tell the Philippines ‘no’ to keep orange grains from showing up in their imports. Imagine how horrible that would be if it happened! I think most people can recognize that fact, and are not lacking in moral grounding. He also learned that genetic engineers aren’t haphazardly throwing genes out in the wild without analyzing the potential consequences. This is what everyone can gain from civil and indeed, friendly dialogue.
On the other hand, someone else who I have talked to through twitter has on many occasions lashed out with abusive language, and holds some very strong opinions about genetic engineering, myself, and the companies involved as well. Talking of #GMO-tards, apparently a reference to some sort of medieval weapon? Others usually add the hashtag of #evil to almost every tweet that has #gmo in it. Recently, even a few comments here on Biofortified have pushed the boundaries of civil dialogue with words such as “drama queen warrior hybrid”, ethical narcissism, and a few other things. While things are far more civil here than elsewhere in the world of this debate, how can we make it better? Jon Stewart on the Daily Show I believe has the answer! Have a looksie:
|The Daily Show With Jon Stewart||Mon – Thurs 11p / 10c|
|Rally to Restore Sanity|
It can seem easy sometimes to ascribe the worst possible characteristics to our opponents and call them immoral, stupid, evil, selfish, and more. But in a discussion described by all those involved as being incredibly important, we need to break down the hyperbolic barriers of communication that exist between us. Maybe this October 30th we could join Stewart (in a virtual sense) in calling for everyone in this debate to Rally to Restore Sanity? Maybe people can “Take it Down a Notch” for me? I don’t want to find out what a “pimp hand” is. Speak your minds, celebrate your disagreements, but remember everyone is human!
(except for me of course, I’m a plant.)
If you are new here or haven’t commented before, please take a moment in the comments below to say hi! Today’s a great day for De-lurking!